Creatine (Cr) is the most popular
nutritional supplement on the market, with yearly sales over $400 million1.
The reason for its popularity is simple: it works! As you probably have read for the hundredth
time...Cr is formed by combining the Amino Acids glycine, arginine, and
methionine and is produced in physiologic amounts by the liver, kidneys, and
pancreas2. In addition to natural synthesis, Cr is also found in
protein-rich sources such as meat and fish. The total daily requirement of Cr
is 2 g/d, approximately half of which comes from in vivo production and the other
half from dietary sources3. The
effects of oral Cr supplementation on contractile performance and metabolism of
skeletal muscle recently have become an area of major interest in exercise
physiology. Cr not only increases work performance but has recently been shown
to increase muscle hypertrophy thru activation of satellite cell activity and
increasing mRNA IGF-1 activity. The
evidence has accumulated over the last several years showing that Cr intake can
elevate muscle Cr stores and improve one's capacity to perform maximal intermittent
exercise such as resistance exercise 4, 5 but has no effect on
endurance type of exercises7.
Creatine Uptake...A
Little Bit Goes a Long Way!
With Cr supplementation, a little
bit goes a long way. The research
suggests that 3-5 grams is sufficient, some researchers suggest a even lower
dosage depending on the amount of dietary Creatine consumed yet the exact
dosage remains to be determined...anything more than that is not going to give
additional gains. In fact the bulk of Cr
ingested at high dosage is excreted in the form of urinary Cr. Nobody likes
pissing money down the drain..so low dose Cr is the way to go. First, during dietary Cr supplementation, Cr
accumulation is most pronounced in those individuals with the lowest initial Cr
stores. When Cr was tested on vegetarian athletes, they made huge gains in strength
because they consumed low endogenous dietary Cr. Dietary sources include beef, tuna, cod,
salmon, herring, and pork. The normal dietary intake of Creatine is 1-2 g/day,
although vegetarians may consume less. Basically, individuals with the lowest starting
intracellular Cr levels would be expected to have the highest initial Cr uptake
rates. Consumption of Cr supplementation results in high intracellular rates that
should rapidly expand the intracellular Cr pool. So what about bodybuilders
whom consume large dietary sources of Cr that give an adult T-REX a run for his
money? Individuals with initially high intracellular Creatine [Cr]i would not
be expected to exhibit the marked increase in Cr uptake rate as for the
individuals with low initial [Cr]i. In addition, the Cr uptake rate could be
downregulated with a sustained extracellular Cr load when [Cr]i is normal or
elevated, although this is reported only in the fast twitch muscle since fast
twitch muscles contain the highest source of [Cr]i.
When a bodybuilder first starts
consuming Cr, accelerated uptake of Cr appears to occur initially, followed by
a decline, possibly related to a decline in Cr transporter (CrT) number and the
modulation of CrT activity associated with an increased [Cr]i8. It's not necessary to take a lot as the Cr
uptake capacity differs among skeletal muscle fiber types. I would not worry about choosing a more
expensive protein powder because it has Cr added to it, especially since after
reading the article bodybuilders should be encouraged to be consuming low
dosage Cr supplementation. It's
interesting that although type II b fibers explosive muscle fibers store more Cr
than slow oxidative type I fibers, its interesting that one study reported that
in rats whom were supplemented Cr for a few days the rates of Cr uptake were greatest in the
slow-twitch muscle fibers and less in the fast-twitch type II fibers. It is interesting the study that noted the Cr
uptake rates were inversely related to the total resting Cr concentration
within the fiber types. Regardless of the absolute value obtained under various
experimental conditions, Cr uptake by the soleus muscle (a slow twitch fiber)
was generally 45-70% greater than the uptake by the white gastrocnemius muscle
(a fast twitch fiber). The greatest Cr uptake rate was observed in the fiber
type with the smallest Cr content (soleus), whereas the opposite was true for
the white gastrocnemius with the largest Cr content. Thus the fiber type with
the highest Cr total content exhibits the lowest uptake rate. Strikingly, the Cr content of the soleus is
~40% less than that of the white gastrocnemius muscle. Curiously, the increase
in Cr uptake was observed in the high-oxidative fiber sections that possess
relatively high mitochondrial contents and the cell fraction identified by
Walzel and coworkers that contain the vast majority of the Cr transport proteins9.
Based on the research low dose Cr supplementation is the way to go as fast
twitch muscle fibers which contain the greatest potential for muscle
hypertrophy can only store a limited amount, thereafter it's either excreted or
shuttled into slow oxidative fibers.